Virginia's Natural Bridge Navigation Blogroll
Search

Archives Credits

Powered by
Movable Type 3.2

Site design by
Sekimori

Amazon Honor System Click Here to Pay Learn More
 
The Commons
Ohio county "cans" recycling
Posted by Andrew Morriss  ·   1 December 2005  ·  Recycling

Lake County, long the "poster child" for recycling in Ohio is dumping the program, according to the Cleveland Plain Dealer, because the costs are too high. The story (link here) is enlightening on the costs of recycling:

Lake County had provided free curbside service to its residents since 1993, paying for it with a multimillion-dollar surplus accumulated from fees charged at the Kirtland landfill. The county paid $1 per household per month, while cities, villages and townships began to pay 69 cents per month in 2003.

That would have increased to $2.25 per household, per month next year, Hodges said. Most local officials told commissioners when polled that the amount would break their budget.

"Everyone wants to be an environmentalist, but it eventually becomes a cost-benefit ratio thing, too," County Commissioner Dan Troy said

The question I would have, if I lived in Lake County, would be: if it isn't worth recycling when the money comes from the local budgets, why was it worth doing when the money came from the "multimillion dollar surplus" from the landfill? Couldn't that money have been better spent on, say, roads, schools, tax relief, parks, etc.?

The problem of governments not facing the true opportunity cost of the resources they spend seems evident here.

Comments
  1. I am a Mentor (lake county) resident and environmental science teacher at the local high school. This decision is extremely disapointing. I don't know why they can't ask the public if they would be willing to pay for it. I think that if the trash pick up in Mentor went to a pay as you throw program it could help cut down a lot on trash fee which can be moved over to the recycle program. I feel really left in the dark about all of this. No one I know saw this coming. It is sad. I emailed the Mentor public works dept. last week and have received no reply yet.

    Posted by: Scott McLaughlin at December 3, 2005 05:29 PM